 |
|
| Our Last 100 Visitors |
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
 |
|
| News / Global Education News |
|
| |
| How Charter Schools Affect Student Outcomes | | By admin |
| Thursday, March 19, 2009 12:00:00 |
Clicks: 738 |
 |
 |
|
|
Thursday, March 19, 2009
How Charter Schools Affect Student Outcomes
While the number of charter schools continues to grow, debate continues about whether charter schools provide a better education experience than traditional public schools. Proponents contend that charter schools expand educational choices for students, increase innovation, improve student achievement and provide much-needed competition to public schools.
Opponents, meanwhile, argue that charter schools lead to increased racial or ethnic stratification of students, skim the best students from traditional public schools, reduce resources for public schools and provide no real improvement in student achievement.
A new RAND study examining charter schools in Chicago, San Diego, Philadelphia, Denver, Milwaukee, and the states of Ohio, Texas and Florida is the first to use longitudinal, student-level data to systematically examine these issues across multiple communities and varied charter laws. It finds that:
*Across locations, there is little evidence that charter schools are producing, on average, achievement impacts that differ substantially from those of traditional public schools. But the evidence is incomplete, because the performance of charter elementary schools -- which constitute a substantial proportion of all charter schools -- cannot be easily assessed.
*There is reason for concern about low performance among two specific groups of charter schools: charter schools in their first year of operation; and, in Ohio, virtual charter schools that serve students remotely via technology rather than in a conventional school building.
*The most promising results for charter schools relate to the long-term outcomes of high-school graduation and college entry.
In the two locations with available data on these critical attainment outcomes (Chicago and Florida), charter high schools appear to have substantial positive impacts, increasing the probability of graduating by 7 to 15 percentage points and increasing the probability of enrolling in college by 8 to 10 percentage points.
*Across seven locations examined, charter schools are generally not skimming the cream in recruiting students: Students entering charter schools generally have prior achievement levels that are comparable to those of their peers in traditional public schools.
*Across locations, charter schools do not appear to produce effects that substantially help or harm student achievement in nearby traditional public schools
While the lack of positive effects on test scores may be disappointing to charter advocates, the positive relationships between charter high school attendance and graduating and going on to college in Chicago and Florida are encouraging, said Ron Zimmer, the report's lead author. These results suggest it may be time to include other important measures when evaluating charter schools.
The report, How Charter Schools Affect Student Outcomes, can be found at www.rand.org
The report authors are Ron Zimmer of Michigan State University, Brian Gill and Kevin Booker of Mathematica Policy Research, Tim Sass of Florida State University, and Stéphane Lavertu and John Witte of University of Wisconsin.
Source: EdNews
http://ednews.org/articles/35226/1/How-Charter-Schools-Affect-Student-Outcomes/Page1.html
|
| |
|
| More Global Education News News |
. The Rise of Youth Entrepreneurship Education
. Girls 'do better in single-sex schools'
. 'Too few' apprenticeships started
. Obama Outlines Plan for Education Overhaul
. Boys and Girls Together, Taught Separately in Public School
. Delaying College for a Year Could Have Benefits
. A Is for Artwork That Lures Bronx Schoolchildren to New Libraries
. Where Education and Assimilation Collide
. Computer Science Programs Make a Comeback in Enrollment
. Report Shows Steep Gains by Students From Abroad
|
|
|
|
|
